Brewster defeated Hen Hud 42-28 in football playoff action at Brewster High School Oct. 21, 2016.
Each week, Josh Thomson will give his predictions on every high school football game in Westchester, Rockland and Putnam Counties. That will include highlighting the five games of the week. Leave your thoughts on this week’s games in the comments, e-mail Josh at jthomson@lohud.com, or reach Josh on Twitter @lohudinsider.
PREDICTIONS: Podcast, playoffs and more in Section 1 quarterfinal picks
SCHEDULE: The complete Section 1 football playoff schedule
THE FIFTH QUARTER: Klein, Scarsdale find the upset formula; plus the Player and Coach of the Week
PODCAST: Our second edition of the Lohud Sports playoff football podcast dropped on Tuesday! If you want to hear my analysis on last week’s games and this week’s semifinals, listen to my breakdown with Leif Skodnick.
Remember: You can find it on Soundcloud or download it or subscribe on iTunes.
Below are my predictions on each of this week’s individual games, including the quarterfinals:
Week 9 predictions —
Class AA semifinals
Saturday, Oct. 29
No. 3 Clarkstown South at No. 2 New Rochelle, 1:30 p.m. — After the way Carmel played New Rochelle last week, it’d be easy to expect this game to be close as well. Not so fast. Remember: New Ro beat South on the road by three touchdowns despite six turnovers. That just won’t happen again. The pick: New Rochelle 27, Clarkstown South 7.
No. 5 Scarsdale at No. 1 Arlington, 6 p.m. — I’m a little apprehensive to pick Scarsdale to win a second straight game on the road. The Raiders are a long way from home again and will face a more physical opponent. However, Scarsdale probably has the better team at this point as long as it can protect the football. The pick: Scarsdale 21, Arlington 17.
Class A semifinals
Friday, Oct. 28
No. 5 Rye at No. 1 Yorktown, 7 p.m. — Rye has beat Yorktown in the playoffs each of the last three seasons. The Huskers should be very motivated to win. They are talented and are more than capable of standing toe to toe with the Garnets. However, I have thought all year that Rye’s best is the best in Class A, so I’ll stick with that here. The pick: Rye 24, Yorktown 21.
No. 3 Somers at No. 2 Brewster, 7 p.m. — This should be a classic. I expect this to be the biggest crowd of the week. It also pits two of the area’s best players head to head in Messiah Horne and Jack Guida. I give Somers a slight edge because it has the more diverse offense, but Brewster might give the Tuskers fits up front. The pick: Somers 21, Brewster 20 (OT).
Class B semifinals
Friday, Oct. 28
No. 4 Ardsley at No. 1 Pleasantville at Parkway Field, 6 p.m. — Pleasantville should be healthy and fresh after last week’s quarterfinal bye. The Panthers needed some time to take control before rallying late to beat Ardsley 31-0 during the regular season. Don’t expect it to be that lopsided, but Ardsley will have a tough time scoring points in the rematch. The pick: Pleasantville 14, Ardsley 0.
Saturday, Oct. 29
No. 6 Valhalla at No. 2 Westlake, 1:30 p.m. — This is a very interesting game. Valhalla took a 17-0 lead when they met during the regular season before Westlake rallied to win 21-17. The Vikings won’t jump ahead like that again. They are dangerous, but Westlake’s defense will be tough to beat. The pick: Westlake 28, Valhalla 13.
Class C semifinals
Saturday, Oct. 29
No. 3 Bronxville at No. 2 Dobbs Ferry, 1:30 p.m. — Bronxville had several players suspended the last time these teams met, which resulted in a 39-7 Dobbs win. That won’t happen again, but Dobbs has had the better season overall and will get the benefit of playing at home. The pick: Dobbs Ferry 26, Bronxville 17.
No. 4 Rye Neck at No. 1 Woodlands, 1:30 p.m. — The Falcons just beat Rye Neck 47-6 on Oct. 15. There’s no reason to expect the semifinal to end much differently. Right now, Woodlands is a strong favorite to win it all in Class C. Its defense has been fierce. The pick: Woodlands 33, Rye Neck 6.
Ardsley defeated Albertus Magnus 22-16 in football action at Edgemont High School Oct. 22, 2016.
Other games:
Thursday, Oct. 27
Lakeland at Byram Hills, 3:45 p.m. — Lakeland 21, Byram Hills 7
Sleepy Hollow at Ossining, 5 p.m. — Sleepy Hollow 34, Ossining 20
John Jay at Hen Hud, 6 p.m. — John Jay 41, Hen Hud 35
Tappan Zee at Harrison, 6 p.m. — Tappan Zee 20, Harrison 7
Friday, Oct. 28
Port Chester at White Plains, 6 p.m. — Port Chester 19, White Plains 14
Carmel at Spring Valley at Torne Valley Field, 6 p.m. — Carmel 21, Spring Valley 13
Eastchester at Panas, 6:30 p.m. — Panas 14, Eastchester 7
Nyack at Suffern, 7 p.m. — Suffern 27, Nyack 13
Ketcham at Fox Lane, 7 p.m. — Fox Lane 28, Ketcham 14
Saturday, Oct. 29
Briarcliff/Hamilton at Lincoln, 11 a.m. — Briarcliff 21, Lincoln 6
Mahopac at Mount Vernon, 11 a.m. — Mount Vernon 20, Mahopac 13
Pawling vs. Yonkers at Roosevelt, 1:30 p.m. — Pawling 19, Yonkers 6
John Jay-East Fishkill at North Rockland, 1:30 p.m. — John Jay 21, North Rockland 13
Saunders vs. Riverside at Gorton High School, 1:30 p.m. — Riverside 27, Saunders 12
Pearl River at Yonkers Montessori, 1:30 p.m. — Pearl River 39, YMA 6
Hackley at Montclair Kimberley, 1:30 p.m. — Monclair Kimberley 34, Hackley 20
Stepinac at Chaminade, 2 p.m. — Stepinac 35, Chaminade 20
St. Luke’s at Rye Country Day, 3:30 p.m. — Rye Country Day 20, St. Luke’s 14
Hudson River Football League
Yonkers Bowl at Saunders High School:
No. 1 Gorton vs. No. 2 Pelham, 1:30 p.m. — Gorton 19, Pelham 13
Class B bowls at Valhalla
Albertus Magnus vs. Nanuet, 12 p.m. — Albertus Magnus 19, Nanuet 14
Putnam Valley vs. Blind Brook, 3 p.m. — Putnam Valley 20, Blind Brook 13
Sunday, Oct. 30
Iona Prep at St. Francis Prep, 1 p.m. — Iona Prep 41, St. Francis Prep 7
Idle: Kennedy
Twitter: @lohudinsider